Skip to main content

Table 4 History and development of Heart allocation (Heart Tier System)

From: Inconsistent values and algorithmic fairness: a review of organ allocation priority systems in the United States

Name

Contributing Author(s)

Year of Publication

Year of Adoption by UNOS

Objective

Categories

Changes to Categories

Heart Tier System (2 tiers)

N/A

N/A

1988

Stratify recipient risks based on clinical treatment

Used for both adults and children.

Status 1:

1) Individuals with an implanted mechanical circulatory support (MCS) device including an intra-aortic balloon pump (IABP), total artificial heart (TAH), ventricular assist device (VAD)

2) Individuals who are continuously intubated

3) Individuals admitted to the intensive care unit for inotropic support.

4) Individuals younger than 6 months.

Status 2: All other patients eligible for transplant.

N/A

Heart Tier System (3 tiers)

N/A

N/A

2005

Stratify recipient risks based on clinical treatment

Status 1 A:

1) Individuals with an implanted mechanical circulatory support (MCS) device including an intra-aortic balloon pump (IABP), total artificial heart (TAH), and extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO)

2) Individuals on continuous inotropic support and hemodynamic monitoring

3) Individuals with dischargeable VADs (> 30 days) or VAD complications

4) Individuals on continuous mechanical ventilation

Status 1B:

1) All other individuals who are stable on LVAD/RVAD

2) Individuals on continuous IV inotropic support without hemodynamic monitoring

Status 2: All other patients eligible for transplant.

Increased in priority:

↑ N/A

Decreased in priority:

↓ All other individuals who are stable on LVAD/RVAD

↓ Individuals on continuous IV inotropic support without hemodynamic monitoring

Heart Tier System (6 tiers)

 

2018

2018

Stratify recipient risks based on clinical treatment

Status 1:

1) ECMO for up to 7 days

2) Implanted, non-dischargeable BiVAD

3) MCS device with life threatening ventricular arrythmias

Status 2:

1) Dischargeable BiVAD/RVAD

2) Non-dischargeable LVAD, IABP, or percutaneous MCS for up to 14 days

3) MCS device failure

4) Total artificial heart

Status 3:

1) Dischargeable LVAD for up to 30 days

2) Individuals on continuous inotropic support and hemodynamic monitoring

3) ECMO after 7 days

4) Non-dischargeable LVAD, IABP, or percutaneous MCS devices after 14 days

5) MCS devices with complications

Status 4:

1) Stable on LVAD

2) Individuals on continuous IV inotropic support without hemodynamic monitoring

3) Congenital Heart Disease

4) Re-transplant

5) Restrictive cardiomyopathy

6) Amyloidosis

7) Hypertrophic myopathy

8) Ischemic heart disease with recurrent angina

Status 5:

1) Multiorgan transplant

Status 6: All other patients eligible for transplant.

Increased in priority:

↑ N/A

Decreased in priority:

↓ Stable on LVAD

↓ Individuals on continuous IV inotropic support without hemodynamic monitoring